A quick perusal of Black Milk Clothing’s website shows a distinct similarity to the controversial company American Apparel. From their models to the clothing style to the website design to even the FONT, just squinting a bit could make you mistake Black Milk Clothing for AA. I’m sure that’s not what they were going for at all (SARCASM ALERT!).

Needless to say, that similarity makes this new article of clothing far less surprising. They’re called muscles leggings, and they are exactly what they sound like. Over at BuzzFeed there is quite the debate going on about whether or not these are sexy or totally gross, and we thought we’d ask our readers to weigh in as well.